Misinterpretation OR Misinformation

 This is in reaction to a news article I read yesterday. The article claimed several violations of the law, viz. Citizenship Act, 1955 while rules wee framed under Citizenship Amendment Act, 2019 (CAA, 2019).

I took my time to read the provisions of the law and the rules. I have found that the claim of the article about illegal immigrants was outrageous as the law has clearly spoken if the targeted beneficiaries could be called illegal immigrants. 

Before going into the details, I better share the link to the news article: 

https://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/caa-will-not-help-persecuted-hindus-sikhs-from-neighbouring-countries-9222168/

In a long video I have explained my reasons why I think the claims in the news article is outrageous. Those are as follows:

• Legislatures (Parliament/ State Assemblies through its members) make laws

• .Judiciary (the judges in the courts of law) interprets the laws (through verdicts/ rulings/ guidelines/ observations),

• Executive (departments of Union and State Governments) implement the law by deriving rules from the laws.

Thus rules which are framed under a law, to implement the law have no scope of violating the law itself.

 

Also, Citizenship Act, 1955, as amended in 2019, never promises Citizenship to illegal immigrants of any religion from any country. RATHER, IT SPELLED OUT A BLANKET WAIVER ON ILLEGAL IMMIGRATION OF THE PEOPLE OF HINDU, SIKH, BUDDHIST, JAIN, CHRISTIAN AND PARSI COMMUNITIES COMING FROM AFGHANISTAN, PAKISTAN AND BANGLADESH TO INDIA BEFORE DECEMBER 31, 2014. Thus rules, under citizenship amendment act 2019, cannot be made to grant Citizenship to illegal immigrants.

Here is my long video:

Let me share with you some useful information:

Amended_Citizenship_Rule-dt[1]._10.9.07.doc: https://www.mha.gov.in/PDF_Other/Citi_Rule-2009.pdf

Order: https://indiancitizenshiponline.nic.in/Documents/UserGuide/ordersection6B_rule_11A.pdf

Guidelines for Applicants : https://indiancitizenshiponline.nic.in/Documents/Annexure.pdf

FOR COMPLETE INFORMATION IN THE MATTER OF INDIAN CITIZENSHIP, YOU CAN READ MY BOOK, INDIAN CITIZENSHIP DECODED. IT IS AVAILABLE FOR PURCHASE AT:  https://www.amazon.in/dp/B09875SJF8

#CAA #CAARules #CAANotification #CAANews #CAA2019 #CAAImplementation #CAAProtests

A Few Videos on Citizenship Amendment Act 2019

 Here are some videos for you about the 2019 amendments of the Citizenship Act, 1955.

The answers are always at: https://www.amazon.in/dp/B09875SJF8

How to break down a law without violating its legal authority?

 

Here’s the answer: https://www.amazon.in/dp/B09875SJF8

Do any of the NRC forms ask you about religion?

 

What do NRC forms look like?

You’ll get your answers here: https://www.amazon.in/dp/B09875SJF8

What is NRC?

 

Is it different from NPR? Are these related to CAA 2019?

Your one stop for answers is here: https://www.amazon.in/dp/B09875SJF8

What is NPR?

 

Is NPR related to CAA 2019?

Get your answers here: https://www.amazon.in/dp/B09875SJF8

Do you know how CAA 2019 will affect you?

 

Are you a citizen of India?

Are you an Overseas Citizen of India?

Are you a Person of Indian Origin?

What would be the effect of CAA 2019 on you?

All your answers are here:  https://www.amazon.in/dp/B09875SJF8

The Truth about CAA 2019

 

Too much noise covers the truth. Would you like to know about the truth of the Citizenship Amendment Act, 2019 of India?

The Citizenship Amendment Act, 2019 is controversial. The amendments made to the Citizenship Act, 1955 in 2019 has made the matter of citizenship of India more valuable than ever. The act has been put to trial.

The trial made the implementation of the law almost impossible. The noise of arguments if the law has violated the constitutional provisions, has been clouded with opinions and uninformed opinions. Can Citizenship Amendment Act, 2019 withstand the trial at court of law as well as the trials of opinion?

If you are looking forward to dazzle in current affairs papers in the civil services examinations, if you are caught in between citizenship of India and another country, if you are looking forward to get back your Indian Citizenship, if you are curious to know how to find your ancestors in legacy data, if you are trying to fathom what is CAA, 2019 and refusing to stay confused by the brouhaha in the media, then this books is a must read for you. 

BUY NOW to get into the details of citizenship laws in India.

https://www.amazon.in/dp/B09875SJF8

What Is in My Book about CAA 2019?

 Too many confusing questions around 2019 amendments of the Citizenship Act? Find simple and straight answers in this one stop answer bank.

The objective of this book is to help readers understand the law on Indian Citizenship by untangling complex phrases of bare acts. Understanding the law may further help in distinguishing between information and misinformation in an environment which is clouded with uninformed opinion.
It can also help build informed opinions.

• This Book can come in handy for the aspirants of examinations for different public services.

• It can also be helpful to those who are in between citizenships of India and other countries and looking forward to obtaining an Overseas Citizen of India Card.

• It can also be a guiding material to those who have somehow lost citizenship of India and seeking a way to acquire it.

• It can also be a guide to finding one’s ancestor in the Legacy Data if Nationwide NRC is ever notified.

• It can be entertaining to the curious souls who have an urge to understand what citizenship of India is beyond brouhaha in the media.

It is a multipurpose book. It aspires to cater to multitudes of needs and various interests.

This book is a quest to find the definition of Indian Citizen through the statutes.

1. It has started with the Constitution of India.

2. It has searched through the provisions of the Citizenship Act, 1955, as amended.

3. It has studied the Citizenship (Registration of Citizens and Issue of National Identity Cards) Rules, 2003.

4. It has apprised the processes of National Register for Indian Citizens followed in Assam.

5. In the end, it has looked into the debate over the Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 2019.

6. In due course it has made observations about the history of amendments of the Citizenship Act, 1955.

It has noted the points of debate over the latest amendments of the aforementioned act. Yet, it abstained from expressing any opinion.

Why be littered with a plethora of uninformed opinions? Get your facts straight. Make informed decisions.
Buy Now: https://www.amazon.in/dp/B09875SJF8

My Book on Indian CAA 2019

 I names my book Indian Citizenship Decoded. I published it on August, 2021 through Amazon's Kindle Direct Publishing. 

Here's the cover:

This book is an apolitical author's break-down of the law.

The book is available here: https://www.amazon.in/dp/B09875SJF8

Relevance of Indian CItizenship Decoded

 As COVID-19 invaded India, the entire media coverage was diverted towards the horror of the pandemic. In the midst of global tragedy, the agricultural reforms act came into effect. The debate hungry populace embarrass the left, the right and the centre of the new law. It appeared that 2019 amendments of the CItizenship Act, 1955 was just passé. 

However, citizenship of India will remain a matter of concern for all the citizens till India stands as a sovereign nation. Therefore, debate over the latest amendments of the Citizenship Act, 1955 is still pertinent to the nation.

This argument can be substantiated in the latest outbursts of protests against CAA in Assam. Current debate is about breach of Assam Accord by CAA, 2019.

Assam Accord is Section 6A of the Citizenship Act, 1955 as amended in 1985 [by Act 65 of 1985, s.2, with effect from December 7, 1985].

It has three landmark years in its definitions of different sections. These are 1964, 1966 and 1971. 

What does each of these years mean?

1964 is the year of the Constituting Foreigners’ Tribunal. It was the first step towards separating illegal immigrants in the entire territory of India. 

1966 is important year because January 1, 1966 was marked as the starting date for persons entering Assam from [specified territory]* whose name was to be deleted from subsequent electoral rolls (voters’ list) as mentioned in Subsection (3) of Section 6A of the Citizenship Act, 1955 as amended.

1971 is important as Midnight of March 24, 1971 was marked to be the end date of entry of persons from [specified territory]* whose name was to be deleted from subsequent electoral rolls (voters’ list) as referred in preceding paragraph.

* As mentioned in Assam Accord, [specified territory] is probably the areas belonging to Pakistan till 1971 and then to Bangladesh. This has not been explained in the Citizenship Act, 1955 as amended till now.

As soon as, a person is detected to be a foreigner by definition of entry to India from [specified territory]* between January 1, 1966 and March 25, 1971 such a person would be removed from the electoral roll though such person can keep their Indian passport.

Moreover, March 25, 1971 is the latest date of publication of the electoral roll to be compiled into the Legacy Data prepared for the National Register of Citizens in Assam. 

This appears to be discordant with the Assam Accord. Assam Accord declined to include people in electoral rolls who entered from the [specified territory]* into India in between January 1, 1966 and March 25, 1971 as soon as these people are identified to be foreigners with Indian Passport. Moreover, the Assam Accord attempted to put an embargo of ten years on these people becoming citizens and subsequently voters in India.

Preparation of Legacy data with electoral rolls published before March 25, 1971 was governed by the RULE 4A & SCHEDULE OF CITIZENSHIP RULES 2003 (As amended by 1. G. S. R. 803(E), dated 9th November, 2009 (with effect from 9/11/2009.) This rule unambiguously declared to exclude all persons identified to be foreigners by provisions of Assam Accord to be excluded from the Legacy Data [Rule 3(2) under Schedule supporting Rule 4A of Citizenship Rule laying out SPECIAL PROVISION AS TO MANNER OF PREPARATION OF NATIONAL REGISTER OF INDIAN CITIZEN IN STATE OF ASSAM]. Thus, the process theoretically resolved the conflict of point of references of definition of citizens on the basis of electoral rolls of 1951 and three subsequent electoral rolls published until March 24, 1971.

The Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 2019 has marked December 31, 2014 to be the last date of entry to India from Pakistan, Afghanistan and Bangladesh for people belonging to defined religious groups to be considered for Indian Citizenship. The matter being sub-judice the framing of rules regarding this proviso of the amendment is still pending. Unless the rules, which are the executing procedure of the act,  under this proviso takes forms and shapes, it cannot be said if this proviso is in discordance with the Assam Accord.

**************** 

Looking for more resolves on the disputes over the Citizenship Act, 1955 and its amendments until now? Then, get your facts straight with “Indian Citizenship Decoded”.

Now available in Amazon and Amazon Kindle Store for prebooking all across the globe through designated market places at https://www.amazon.in/dp/B09875SJF8 

****************

The paperback is available now in selected marketplaces from all over the globe through https://www.amazon.com/dp/B098GTZYKK 

****************

More about the book:

Why #IndianCitizenshipDecoded

More about Why  #IndianCitizenshipDecoded

Prebooking #IndianCitizenshipDecoded in Different  Marketplaces

SUBSCRIBE to keep watch on subsequent posts on the book.

Downloading #IndianCitizenshipDecoded in Different Marketplaces

 

In my previous blog I have elaborated the content of the book [here]. Hope, you have found the content useful. 

The content can be pretty useful for persons who are appearing in competitive exams for public services in India.

It can be useful to students abroad who need to maintain their Indian Citizenship.

It can also be useful for people who are treading in between Indian citizenship and citizenship of another country and vice versa.

It can also be useful for the people who are sceptical about the National Citizenship Register and how NRC would affect them.

Moreover, it can be useful to everyone who is curious about the true nature of the Citizenship (Amendement) Act, 2019 and the nature of controversy around it.

In an ambition to be more useful I am sharing herewith the details of having the book.

It is available in both Kindle format and Paperback.

The paperback is already available for purchase in nine (9) marketplaces. It can be accessed by this link from anywhere on the earth. It would be better while ordering a paperback to log in to the nearest geographic Amazon Marketplace.

If anyone is trying to purchase Indian Citizenship Decoded from Pakistan or Bangladesh, it would be better if they buy it from amazon.in.

If anyone is buying the book from South Korea, it will be better if they access amazon.jp.

For people in Newzealand the nearest Amazon marketplace is amazon.au.

Nearest marketplace for Finland is amazon.de.

Then there is amazon.co.uk, amazon.fr, amazon.es and so on as detailed below:

The United States (amazon.com),

The United Kingdom (amazon.co.uk), 

Denmark (amazon.de), 

France (amazon.fr),.

 España [Spain] (amazon.es),

Italy (amazon.it),

Japan (amazon.co.jp),

Canada (amazon.ca),

Australia(amazon.com.au)

August 15 is the Independence Day of India. The book is about to be released on Kindle is about citizenship of India. For dramatic effect, the release date of the book, “Indian CItizenship Decoded” has been set on August 1, 2021, the onset of the month of Independence.

The Kindle edition will be available in more marketplaces than the paperback. Also, the marketplace does not matter as long as purchasers can access any of the marketplace domain name (.com, .in, .co.uk et cetera) from purchasers’ geography while buying digital copy. However, if anyone finds any obstacle in accessing any domain, they can try the nearest geographic market place. The domains and geographies are as follows:

amazon.com > the United States

amazon.co.uk> the United Kingdom

amazon.de>  Denmark

amazon.fr> France

amazon.es>España (Spain)

amazon.it>Italy

amazon.nl> Netherland

amazon.co.jp>Japan

amazon.com.br>Brazil

amazon.ca>Canada

amazon.com.mx>Mexico

amazon.com.au>Australia

amazon.in> India

About Prebooking/Purchasing/ Free Download

Prebooking means if a purchaser pays for the book on Kindle Store anytime before August 1, 2021 then the book will be downloaded to the purchaser's device on August 1, 2021.

Purchasing means paying for the book as online shopper. It would enable the shoppers to read the book on their devices.

Free Download mean by clicking buy button the shoppers can download the book free of cost on their respective devices.

The devices can be a Kindle reader or an iPhone/ iPad with Kindle App or an android phone/table with Kindle App. Also, can be a desktop/laptop computer where browser is the reader.

For downloading Kindle App the purchaser should go to - 

Google play store for android phone/ tablet; then search by typing “Kindle”, then press/touch “Install”

Or, to the Apple store for iPhone/iPad; then search by typing “Kindle”, then press/touch “get”.

Those who just downloaded the Kindle App and those who already had the app now can open the App, then type in “Indian Citizenship Decoded” on the search bar and search for “Indian Citizenship Decoded”; as the book appears you can try any one of the buttons, “Prebook” (Till July 31, 2021), “buy” or “borrow” (since August 1, 2021). 

Following are the links to videos for finding “Indian Citizenship Decoded” on Kindle Store and Reader (App).

Downloading Kindle on Android phone/ tablet for #Indian #Citizenship Decoded

Downloading Kindle on iPhone/ iPad for Indian Citizenship Decoded

Downloading Indian Citizenship Decoded on Kindle App

Prebooking of Indian Citizenship Decoded

**************************

More about the book will appear in subsequent posts. 

SUBSCRIBE to keep watch.

****************

The Kindle Edition of Indian Citizenship Decoded is now available in Amazon and Amazon Kindle Store for prebooking all across the globe through designated market palces at https://www.amazon.com/Indian-Citizenship-Decoded-Emotional-Predilections-ebook/dp/B09875SJF8/ref=tmm_kin_swatch_0?_encoding=UTF8&qid=&sr=

****************

The paperback is available now in selected marketplaces from all over the globe through https://www.amazon.com/dp/B098GTZYKK?ref_=pe_3052080_397514860

More about Why #IndianCitizenshipDecoded

 I have so far divulged [Live in this link] that Indian Citizenship Decoded/ Beyond Emotional Outbursts and Political Predilections have come into existence from an urge to know the definition of citizenship in India. With then ensuing controversy over the recent amendments of the Citizenship Act, 1955, curiosity also dragged the search to find the root of the controversy. Thus, the book is full of details about the controversy regarding the controversy.

In my previous post about the book [linked here], I have shed light on how I have approached the bare acts. The approach has been the same in discussing the stance of the Constitution of India on the matters of citizenship.

The book opens with the perception of citizenship in the Constitution of India. Then it goes through the nitty gritties of the Citizenship Act, 1955. The chapter has highlighted all the amendments made by the Citizenship (Amendment), 2019 with the Act of 1955. This has been the blatant attempt to understand the seed of the controversy.

As an obvious outcome, the book has gone through understanding the Citizenship (Registration of Citizens and Issue of National Identity Cards) Rules, 2003. It made clear that the processes followed in preparation of the National Register of the Citizens in Assam was execution of the aforementioned rule.

Therefore, the step by step process of NRC has been noted in the book. The forms used, the enumerations in the forms - all were discussed with reference to the aforementioned rules. 

Finally, the book took on the controversy. Sifting through the cacophony, the debate over the legitimacy of the amendments of 2019 of the Citizenship Act, 1955 were narrowed down only to two questions. Those two questions have been discussed with references to the Constitution of India, verdicts by the Honorable Supreme Court of India, some research papers, some reports by the foreign governments and by the United Nations and some international Non-governmental organizations.

Yet the book abstained from putting forward its own opinion.

****************

More about the book will appear in subsequent posts. 

SUBSCRIBE to keep watch.

****************

The Kindle Edition is now available in Amazon and Amazon Kindle Store for prebooking all across the globe through designated market palces at https://www.amazon.com/Indian-Citizenship-Decoded-Emotional-Predilections-ebook/dp/B09875SJF8/ref=tmm_kin_swatch_0?_encoding=UTF8&qid=&sr=

****************

The paperback is available now in selected marketplaces from all over the globe through https://www.amazon.com/dp/B098GTZYKK?ref_=pe_3052080_397514860